Hino reaches $236 million settlement with CARB

California Attorney General Rob Bonta and the California Air Resources Board (CARB) announced Wednesday a $236.5 million settlement with Hino Motors, subsidiary of Toyota Motors Corporation. The settlement is part of a larger $1.5 billion settlement Toyota reached with the state.

CARB states the settlement includes approximately $30.3 million to compensate CARB’s Hybrid and Zero-Emission Truck and Bus Voucher Incentive Project (HVIP) and settle the California Attorney General’s claims that Hino fraudulently obtained low emissions vehicle subsidies from the state and allegedly violated California laws including the False Claims Act and Unfair Competition Law.

The settlement also includes a payment of about $206 million to CARB for civil penalties and mitigation programs to reduce excess nitrogen oxide (NOx) emissions. Hino also agreed to provide a voluntary fix for some of the affected vehicles at no cost to owners.

The settlement continues a busy week for CARB, which revoked its waiver request from the EPA for its Advanced Clean Fleets rule Tuesday.

[RELATED: ATD 'pleased and relieved' as CARB abandons Advanced Clean Fleets]

“Hino knowingly took unlawful advantage of California’s incentives designed to accelerate the adoption of clean transportation technologies, which safeguard the health and safety of Californians from pollution,” says Attorney General Bonta. â€śAt the California Department of Justice, we will continue to hold manufacturers like Hino accountable for breaking California’s laws. I want to thank our federal and state partners for their collective work on reaching this critical settlement.”

CARB’s investigation began in 2019 when Hino’s certification applications were reviewed and found inconsistencies in the emissions data. CARB worked alongside the EPA, and further testing revealed undisclosed and unapproved auxiliary emission control devices on 2010-2019 model year J05E and J08E heavy-duty engines used in both on-road trucks and off-road equipment. CARB says these engines were found to emit excess NOx, with some models emitting several times more than allowed by federal and state standards. 

[RELATED: ATA forecasting freight bounce back in 2025]

The Attorney General's office found Hino defrauded CARB into accepting Hino’s trucks into the HVIP, a program that incentivizes the sale of approved hybrid vehicles, by using state funds to provide point-of-sale discounts. Hino qualified for HVIP incentive funding by falsely claiming that its trucks complied with state and federal law. CARB says the original misrepresentations occurred in 2012, and all Hino models approved for HVIP in the following eight years relied on the original HVIP approval. Under the HVIP, dealers were able to sell Hino trucks at discounted prices. The dealers would then submit vouchers to CARB for payment. The vouchers for each truck ranged from $7,500 to $37,000, and CARB received a total of 1,606 fraudulent vouchers, CARB says.

After a voluntary disclosure by Hino of false statements in its HVIP application, CARB states the Attorney General found Hino violated state laws including the False Claims Act and Unfair Competition Law. Hino regularly altered emission test data, conducted tests improperly, or entirely fabricated data without conducting any underlying tests. Hino also failed to disclose multiple software functions that could reduce the effectiveness of the emission control systems in their engines, increasing emissions that harm Californians’ health and safety, CARB states.

"CARB's rigorous air quality regulations protect communities from harmful pollutants that cause a host of serious health problems,” says CARB Chair Liane Randolph. “Manufacturers should know that we will continue to use our enforcement authority to hold companies responsible when they try to skirt the rules to prioritize profit over public health. We appreciate Hino's cooperation during this investigation, and hope this settlement serves as a reminder of our shared responsibility to ensure clean air for all Californians."

Looking for your next job?
Careersingear.com is the go-to platform for the Trucking industry. Don’t just find the job you need; find the job you want with the company that wants you!
Learn how to move your used trucks faster
With unsold used inventory depreciating at a rate of more than 2% monthly, efficient inventory turnover is a must for dealers. Download this eBook to access proven strategies for selling used trucks faster.
Download
Used Truck Guide Cover